| Date | Leader |
|---|---|
| 1840's | Bands existed in Berlin, Ontario as early as 1845 but no known records were kept of leaders during this period. |
| 1855-1866 | Heinrich Glebe |
| 1866-1875 | William Kaiser |
| 1875-1880 | John Smith |
| 1880-1882 | Noah Zeller |
| 1882-1884 | Harry Hunt |
| 1884-1886 | Walter Hume |
| 1886-1887 | John Smith |
| 1887 | Alex Russel |
| 1888-1889 | T.W. Cline |
| 1889-1890 | J.W. Trendell |
| 1890-1892 | H.C. Heinicke |
| 1893 | Noah Zeller |
| 1894-1899 | William Forder |
| 1900-1912 | Noah Zeller |
| 1913-1925 | Harry Stockton |
| 1925-1967 | George H. Ziegler |
| 1967-1974 | Arthur Freund |
| 1971-1972 | Dr. James Gayfer |
| 1974-1978 | Ray K. Sweezey |
| 1978-1984 | Dave Howell |
| 1984-1987 | Ben Scott |
| 1987-2006 | Paul Schalm |
| 2007-Present | Dave Davidson |